The Craftsman American Tavern

In the heart of Eagle River, Wisconsin, lies The Craftsman American Tavern—a stylish establishment that harmoniously combines Northwoods cozy with modern elegance. Opened in 2020 by brothers Matthew and Brian Justice, this tavern quickly evolved from a simple bar into a true gastronomic landmark for residents and visitors of the USA.

The interior of the establishment deserves special attention: it is dominated by hand-finished wood, creating a uniquely warm atmosphere. The spacious bar and cozy dining areas invite visitors not just for a bite to eat, but for a complete aesthetic and culinary experience. The philosophy of the tavern is built on the principle of "A Job Well Done," which is evident in every detail—from the table setting to the selection of drinks.

The high quality of the cuisine and service is confirmed by an impressive 4.5 rating and the prestigious Travelers’ Choice award from Tripadvisor. They serve classic American dishes with a signature twist, focusing on both traditional meat recipes and modern vegan options. This place is perfect for those seeking a quality getaway in a pleasant setting.

For your convenience, we have gathered the main contact details for the establishment in the table below. It is recommended to check for table availability in advance, especially during the peak tourist season.

A visit to The Craftsman American Tavern is primarily an opportunity to treat yourself to excellent food. Foodies should definitely try the famous cheese curds, prepared here according to a special recipe, as well as the variety of pizzas and signature burgers. For those following a plant-based diet, the menu includes interesting options such as the Impossible burger with cranberries.

For beverage enthusiasts, the tavern offers an impressive list: more than 20 varieties of craft beer on tap and a carefully crafted cocktail menu. The spacious bar area encourages socializing, and for those looking for a bit of entertainment, there are games set up in the back of the room. During the warmer months, it is particularly pleasant to spend time on the outdoor terrace, enjoying the fresh air and the lively atmosphere of downtown.

Families with children will also find a warm welcome—a special kids' menu is provided for younger guests. The polite and attentive staff is always ready to help with recommendations, and the option to order takeout is a great bonus for those planning a picnic by one of the region's many lakes.

The Craftsman American Tavern is located in the heart of the city at 118 S Main St. Thanks to its central location, the tavern is easily accessible on foot from many popular spots; for example, the Northwoods Children's Museum is just a few minutes' walk away. If you are staying at nearby hotels, such as the Best Western Derby Inn, the walk to the bar will take very little time.

For those traveling by car through Wisconsin, the city is accessible via the region's main highways. Parking spaces are available in downtown Eagle River, though traffic can be heavier during the summer months due to the influx of tourists. Using a navigator with the coordinates 45.9158838, -89.251024 will help you quickly find your way on-site.

Public transport in this part of the USA is not as developed as in major metropolitan areas, so guests most often choose taxis or rental cars. If you are staying in the suburbs or by the lakes, a taxi ride to Main Street is the fastest and most convenient way to reach your destination.

The story of The Craftsman American Tavern began in 2020 when brothers Matthew and Brian Justice decided to realize their dream of creating a high-level gastronomic space in their hometown. The building on South Main Street underwent an extensive renovation, with special attention paid to every detail. Brian Justice personally handled the woodwork for the interior, striving to emphasize authenticity and craftsmanship in every line.

Initially, the project was intended as a local spot with refined cuisine so that residents wouldn't have to travel outside Eagle River for a quality dinner. However, during construction, it became clear that the tavern could become a true landmark for the entire area. The name "Craftsman" reflects the philosophy of "A Job Well Done," which is evident in both the design and the approach to food preparation.

In its five years of existence, the establishment has not only stood its ground against the region's natural attractions but has also become an important part of the local culture. The owners constantly refine the menu based on guest feedback and maintain the atmosphere of a welcoming home where tradition and quality are valued.

To fully enjoy the atmosphere of The Craftsman American Tavern, the average visitor is recommended to set aside 1.5 to 2.5 hours. This is ample time for a leisurely lunch or dinner, tasting a couple of craft beers, and taking in the establishment's unique interior.

If you plan to visit with a large group to play games in the back of the bar or spend the evening on the outdoor terrace, your stay may extend to 3 hours. During peak hours, especially in summer, it's worth considering potential wait times for orders, so it's best not to plan your visit in a hurry.

Please note that the operating hours of The Craftsman American Tavern may change depending on the season or holidays. Currently, the establishment follows this schedule:

• Tuesday, Thursday: 12:00 PM – 9:00 PM
• Friday, Saturday: 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM
• Monday, Wednesday, Sunday: Closed

Since working hours can vary, it is recommended to check the official website or call to confirm before your visit to ensure your experience is perfect.

Its downtown location makes a visit to the tavern an ideal starting point for further exploring the local flavor. A stroll through the neighborhood will allow you to feel the rhythm of a small American town and find several more interesting places to relax.